Customer Experience

What a personalised retail experience means for consumers

Michael Baker
Smarter Writer

Michael Baker is a retail consultant and vice-chair of the ICSC's Asia-Pacific Research Council

Michael Baker
Smarter Writer

Michael Baker is a retail consultant and vice-chair of the ICSC's Asia-Pacific Research Council

Can your bricks-and-mortar store compete with e commerce tactics and still retain customers?

Charging different customers a different price for the same product at the same time is called price discrimination, and it is being driven to a whole new level in the retail industry under various guises, some of which are called “personalising the shopping experience”. Customers in the airline and hospitality sectors have accepted this variable pricing without much complaint. Will retail shoppers accept it? That depends on how far retailers push the envelope.

cartoon men with antenna on head

The price is right

In 2013, the Canadian company, 360pi, a specialist in strategic pricing, tracked the prices being charged by 28 retailers, including Amazon. “On average, Amazon changes prices on 15-20 per cent of its assortment every day,” says Jenn Markey, 360pi’s Vice President of Marketing. “Amazon made more than three million daily price changes last November, but this kind of dynamic pricing is now attainable for most retailers.”Amazon uses ‘robo-pricing’, a technology that monitors competitor prices and then re-prices identical products at Amazon by an amount calculated to siphon away sales. However, this is only variable pricing’s Level One. Retailers are only just getting warmed up.

Amazon made more than three million daily price changes last November.

- Jenn Markety, 360PI

Top dollar

At variable pricing’s Level Two, customers are being charged a different price for an identical item, but it’s called ‘yield management’. For example, the last time you rolled your luggage into hotel room 908, chances are good that the person in 907 paid a different price for an identical space. This does not constitute price discrimination so long as the hotel is charging the same price at any given moment in time to all customers, even if they are changing that uniform price quite regularly.

However, some retailers offer different prices to customers at the same moment in time, based on each customer’s purchase history and his or her perceived ‘willingness to pay’ to get the highest possible margin. In December 2012 The Wall Street Journal ran an exposé of several companies that were doing this, including major US office supplies and home improvement chains. But the practice does not sit well with many people, who view it as deceitful and likely to alienate any customer who gets wind of it. Online retailers can easily conceal such price discrimination but what if the concept is taken into a bricks-and-mortar store? Welcome to variable pricing’s Level Three.

UK home improvement chain B&Q is trialling digital shelf labels that can identify a passing customer by his or her smart phone signal, tap into his or her loyalty program or purchase history, then tailor the price (higher or lower than usual) displayed onthe shelf label.

The bottom line

Good idea or not? That would presumably depend on whether you are the customer getting the better price or the curious person trailing behind who finds out he’s paying more. A retailer may be sacrificing some of its rank-and-file customers on the altar of pleasing its most loyal ones, which does not seem like a particularly sound long-term strategy.

Should in-store price discrimination prove too difficult to practise, it will nonetheless become a staple of online retailing. Why? Because different people have a different threshold price they will pay for any item. If the technology is there to profile each customer, then retailers have a new lever to improve sales and margins.

Verdict

Variable pricing is here to stay because it has a powerful economic rationale. More questionable is whether it can be practised successfully in physical stores. The answer to that question is “probably not”. Once the word gets around that retailers are sorting their customers into winners and losers, customers will not be amused.

Man rubbing his eyes while working on a laptop
Customer Experience
Customer Experience
Are you making these common online marketing mistakes?

We’re in the middle of a digital marketing revolution, with an array of digital tools and technologies available to small businesses. But, as with any tool, it’s how you use it...

Tips for getting the most out of email marketing
Growth
Growth
Tips for getting the most out of email marketing

To make sure you’re maximising your email marketing campaigns, we’ve compiled a list of the best email marketing features – and why you need to start using these now. With 79 ...

Women looking at screens in an office.
Tech Solutions
Tech Solutions
Smarter Action Plan: Switching to a new broadband plan

If you mean business, then you should be making the most of a business-grade broadband plan. This action plan includes step-by-step advice to take the pain out of finding and s...

Nelly Phelan, senior marketing and communications manager for ELK fashion and accessories.
Customer Experience
Customer Experience
Search engine marketing: can small businesses be more competitive?

The majority of Australian customers regularly use search engines to find and research a business, but only 26 per cent of small businesses use search engine optimisation (SEO)...