Ross Greenwood
Smarter Writer

Ross Greenwood is the Nine Network's business and finance editor and hosts Money News on 2GB

Ross Greenwood
Smarter Writer

Ross Greenwood is the Nine Network's business and finance editor and hosts Money News on 2GB

What’s in a brand trademark? A lot of lawyers’ fees if you don’t get it right. Ross Greenwood looks at what works, and what doesn’t.

There’s always a lot of talk about the value of a ‘brand’, and how brand recognition is so important. But what happens when you think someone is imitating your brand and, in effect, stealing some of that value? Well, that’s what trademarks are all about. 

 

cartoon farmer trademark stamping cow

In Australia, a trademark can be a word, shape, sound — the MGM lion’s roar, for example — or a colour. Cadbury owns the colour purple, specifically Pantone 2685c purple, for its Dairy Milk Chocolate in Australia, but recently lost a legal case against Nestlé to trademark it in the UK.

You can even trademark a scent in Australia. A ‘Eucalyptus radiata’ fragrance is trademarked for use in golf tees. Its scent is said to calm you so your golf shots are more accurate!

It’s all about having something that differentiates your product from another. But protecting that trademark can be hard work.

I spoke with Michaela Whitbourn, legal affairs editor from The Sydney Morning Herald, about a coffee trademark battle that amounted to a whole lot more than a hill of beans.

Ross Greenwood: What do the words ‘cinque stelle’ and ‘oro’ mean to you? If you’re Italian, you will know that I’m talking about the words for ‘five stars’ and ‘gold’. But those words have been the subject of a trademark case. 

Vittoria Coffee, controlled by the Cantarella family, has been around in Australia for years. They trademarked the words ‘oro’ and ‘cinque stelle’ in Australia in 2000 and 2001, but they lost the rights in 2013, when the Federal Court overturned a previously successful lawsuit against Modena, a rival coffee distributor. Now it’s gone to the High Court. Michaela, can you explain exactly what the argument was?

Michaela Whitbourn: The argument put forward by Modena, which imports the rival coffee brand Caffe Molinari, was that ‘cinque stelle’ and ‘oro’ were common descriptive words used by Italian speakers (meaning ‘five stars’ and ‘gold’, respectively), and were not capable of distinguishing one brand from another.

That argument found favour in the Federal Court, but the High Court said that these words were not well recognised in Australia, a predominantly English-speaking country, and that they were capable of differentiating Vittoria Coffee from other brands, and therefore they could be trademarked. 

RG: Now does this mean that if I were to take a common word from a different language and trademark it here in Australia, then maybe I could use it to distinguish my brand from everyone else’s? That’s almost what the court’s ruled, isn’t it?

MW: Yes, that’s what the High Court ruled in the Cantarella coffee case. English words that are in common usage in Australia and that are used to describe a particular product, cannot be trademarked because they are words that ALL traders should be allowed to use. But, when you start using foreign words, not everyone knows what they mean. They may come to be associated with a particular brand, and it is possible to obtain a trademark over them. 

RG: Now the other one that has come up is Apple’s ‘App Store’. And, in this case, it seems that Apple may have lost the case in the Federal Court so far.

MW: Apple would like to have a trademark over the words ‘App Store’, but the Registrar of Trade Marks refused registration of Apple’s trademarks in March 2013. Apple appealed that decision to the Federal Court, but the Federal Court found that this was a descriptive term, and it wasn’t capable of being trademarked by Apple. 

RG: The intellectual property law firm Watermark reportedly estimated that the appeal alone could have cost Apple between $100,000 and $200,000. Seeing as the company is valued at more than $700 billion on the stockmarket right now, that’s chump change. But the fact is it shows that it can be relatively expensive, for a small business especially, to try and protect its own brand and its own name.

MW: Absolutely, and legal representation is expensive, even for short stints of time

So those figures aren’t surprising, although they’re pretty eye-popping for ordinary consumers.

Ross Greenwood’s verdict

Trademarks are tricky things, but one way to avoid a headache is by making up your own word, and to get proper trademark legal advice before adopting a new brand. I can think of at least one company that has done that. It’s called Google, and in 2014 its brand value was estimated at US$107.43 billion.

Image shows two people using free Wi-Fi in a café.
Tech Solutions
Tech Solutions
Be my guest: How guest Wi-Fi services benefit small businesses as well as customers

While ordering a coffee or taking a break while shopping, many customers will take advantage of free Wi-Fi. However, there are many ways small businesses can also benefit by pr...

Example of some of the analysis featured in the Business Benchmark Report.
Success Stories
Success Stories
How does your business compare? Find out with a tailored benchmarking report

Every 2018 Telstra Business Awards entrant receives a custom benchmarking report packed with tailored business analysis relative to other small businesses, plus clear advice on...

Violet Roumeliotis, 2017 Telstra Business Woman of the Year.
Success Stories
Success Stories
Press for progress: Business Woman of the Year helps families find their feet

Violet Roumeliotis, Telstra Australian Business Woman of the Year 2017, shares her experiences as a migrant and woman helping to improve people's lives. As told to Stuart Ridle...

Jen Geale, Mountain Bikes Direct
Success Stories
Success Stories
Being digital-only gives Mountain Bikes Direct the competitive advantage

Since launching online in 2012, Mountain Bikes Direct has supplied customers Australia-wide with specialist mountain bike equipment. Co-founder Jen Geale says e-commerce made i...